I wish I had been that creep that you
Wanted me to be
I wish I would've cheated and lied
If only I had been that creep that you
Wanted me to be
You'd still be here by my side

[Chorus] But nice guys finish last
It's a cliché but it's true
The good guys always get the shaft
They never get the girl like you
I should've tried a little harder
But I didn't know the game
My mom and daddy raised me right so I guess
They're part to blame
I should've treated you like you treated me when

You tore my heart in tow
You should have stayed a little longer
You could have taught me how to lie
We could have been the perfect couple I am sure
I would've been your favorite creep, I would've
Been your perfect guy
I would've been what you hate living life most for

[Chorus] I wish I had been that creep that
Wanted me to be
I wish I would've cheated and lied
If only I had been that creep that you
Wanted me to be
You'd still be here by my side