Verse One:
You said you'd call me at five,
But you lied so obviously.
I'm not the one on your mind,
But I won't cry.
You have me so hypnotized,
And it's crazy but every word you say I believe.
But your acting different,
So distant and quick to me.
I know if I stay, it'll just cause more pain.
But I can't let you go.

Chorus:
And Baby, why do you have to be so amazing to me, and I try just to walk away but your blue eyes make me stay.
And baby you make this confusing even when I'm loosing.
And baby why do you have to be so amazing to me.

Verse Two:
You said you hate to talk on the phone, so baby when I got home and we were finally alone. All wrapped up in your arms in bed. You swore you'd be here till the end. But it's different now and I don't know how things got this way. You seem so far away and I know if I stay, it'll just cause more pain. But I can't let you go.

Chorus:
And baby, why do you have to be so amazing to me, and I try just to walk away but your blue eyes make me stay.
And baby you make this confusing even when I'm loosing.
And baby why do you have to be so amazing to me.

Verse Three:
It's like I'm holding on to someone I don't even know anymore. Everything's changed and you're not the same. Please come back through that door.

Chorus:
And Baby, why do you have to be so amazing to me, and I try just to walk away but your blue eyes make me stay. And baby why can't you love me now and leave me left out. And baby why do you have to be so amazing?…