[Verse 1] Sweet as yesterday, love
It smelled like burnt gardenias
We both had the day off
We drove out to Arcadia
Seventh in the nation
For homes in money magazine
Some locals had the day off
We broke in through their back door screen

[Prechorus] Heart racing you to the bedroom
Lay me down
I'll be the big spoon

[Chorus] Broke all the mirrors in the house
Glittering splinters on the couch
Oh what a feeling
When all I believe in
Is just you and me and no one else

Dancing in our balaclavas
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers
Dancing in our balaclavas
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers

[Verse 2] Dumb as daisy petals
We left our fingerprints inside
We set the house on fire
And prayed that God will bless our crimes
Seven in the evening
How sad to leave it all behind
It was a good day, Love
I'll always have it on my mind

[Chorus] Broke all the mirrors in the house
Glittering splinters on the couch
Oh what a feeling
When all I believe in
Is just you and me and no one else

Dancing in our balaclavas
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers
Dancing in our balaclavas
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers

[Bridge] Close your eyes and say "It's my birthday"
Cause we've got cake
And we're eating it too

[Outro] Dancing in our Balaclavas
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers
Let's pretend we're star-crossed lovers