[Verse 1] I sat down at the piano, even though I don't really play
She barely even looked at me as I stumbled for words to say
And it's a good thing I was sitting down as her hand struck the keys
For the sound I heard in another situation would have taken me to my knees

[Chorus] As I fell for the first, the last, and only time
I had time to think it through
And if I ever had to choose between everyone and you
If I ever had to choose between everyone and you
I'd choose you

[Verse 2] We'd spend whole nights just talking
Planing homes, careers, and trips
Discussing every single subject
Like time, space, and paperclips
There were times where we might disagree
Or maybe even fight
But in the silent moments between, I knew it just felt right

[Chorus] As I fell for the first, the last, and only time
I had time to think it through
And if I ever had to choose between everyone and you
If I ever had to choose between everyone and you
I'd choose you

[Chorus] As I fell for the first, the last, and only time
I had time to think it through
And if I ever had to choose between everyone and you
If I ever had to choose between everyone and you
I'd choose you